Love Hurts, details a mother's worst nightmare. Last summer British mother-of-two, ALISON SCHULTZ fled from her American home in Staten Island, New Jersey after her husband EDDIE had repeatedly beaten her over a five-year period. Returning home to Preston she gradually settled back into her life, trying to put her abusive marriage behind her. This happy ending turned out to be just the beginning of Alison's struggle to escape her abusive husband

.
love you.jpg (45402 bytes)

Despite being wanted by the authorities after a pub brawl in Britain, Eddie managed to obtain Legal Aid and pursued his wife relentlessly through the British courts. The courts' judgment forced Alison, under the Hague Convention, to return to the US. From being an abused wife, she'd become an international child abductor. "I thought, having the courage to leave this marriage and the violence, that I'd done the right thing," she explains. The courts didn't agree.

al at table.jpg (46312 bytes)


In America, Alison hired a new lawyer and further legal proceedings were set in motion. Eddie, unable to afford a lawyer, employed a strange character called JOHN MIDDLETON from the National Coalition for the Rights of Men. Confident that Alison was at fault, Middleton nevertheless claims he would immediately take Alison's side if Eddie became violent.

negs 4 shot a.bmp (1470008 bytes)

Meanwhile at home, daughter EMILY was caught in the middle of the battle. She was profoundly affected by her father's actions and chillingly recalls: "One day my daddy put his hand over my mummy's mouth so she couldn't breathe". Alison points to evidence of Eddie's temper in the house: "He'd been aggravated about some cheque he'd been given and he couldn't cash it and he came and he proceeded to kick the radiator, he hit the microwave as well ... big dent".


emplay.jpg (25311 bytes)


At the meeting to discuss the terms of their separation, arguments mount concerning custody, Alison's family, and the money from the sale of the house. Eddie resented the fact that Alison comes from a wealthy background. "Your family is loaded beyond the gills" he exclaims. He benefited from this wealth, however, when an agreement was made giving Eddie $25,000, the family home (bought with Alison's money), an assurance to pay off his credit card debts and an agreement for the children to be flown over to America twice a year at Alison's parents' expense. In return Eddie, grudgingly, allowed the children to go home.

walking in low sun.jpg (46045 bytes)

But later Eddie's anger spilled over into violent action. BARBARA CARUSO, Alison's neighbour describes the assault she witnessed: "I saw her husband drag her out by her hair, throw her down the steps and kick her in the head... I screamed to my husband call 911 because he's going to kill her," she recalls.



In hiding, the hotel and legal bills have mounted up until judgment day arrives in court. To get to this point has cost Alison's family over $100,000 in legal fees alone. This time the judge ruled in Alison's favour and the nightmare was over. After years of fear and abuse, Alison was free to return home with her children.

ed and kids.jpg (52791 bytes)
 

 

Photography by Todd Liebler

Assistant Producer Clio David

Edited by David G Hill

Directed by Agnieszka Piotrowska

Twenty Twenty Production for Channel 4